The 2023 D3hoops.com All-America team is our 26th annual national awards, selected by D3hoops.com staff from nominees for D3hoops.com All-Region.
Player of the Year: Alex Sobel, Sr., F., Middlebury
Rookie of the Year: Jalen Overway, C, Calvin
Coach of the Year: Sean Smith, North Park
| First team | ||||
| G | Tyson Cruickshank | Wheaton (Ill.) | Sr. | Highlands Ranch, Colo. |
| G | Raheem Anthony | St. Mary’s (Minn.) | Sr. | Chicago, Ill. |
| F | Christian Parker | Mount Union | Jr. | Canton, Ohio |
| F | Miles Mallory | Randolph-Macon | Sr. | Beltsville, Md. |
| F | Alex Sobel | Middlebury | Sr. | Setauket, NY |
| Second team | ||||
| G | Josiah Johnson | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Sr. | Big Sandy, Texas |
| G | Mitch Prendergast | Case Western Reserve | Sr. | Dallas, Texas |
| F | Levi Borchert | UW-Oshkosh | Sr. | Kimberly, Wis. |
| F | Jeff Hunter | Keene State | Sr. | Hudson, Mass. |
| C | Jared Houston | Emerson | Sr. | Norwood, Mass. |
| Third team | ||||
| G | Spencer Freedman | New York University | Sr. | Pacific Palisades, Calif. |
| G | Josh Angle | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps | Sr. | Lake Oswego, Ore. |
| G | Octavio Brito | Keene State | So. | Lincoln, RI |
| F | Jackson Meshanic | Hobart | Sr. | Columbia, Conn. |
| F | Brendan Mora | Pomona-Pitzer | Jr. | Palo Alto, Calif. |
| Fourth team | ||||
| G | Vinny DeAngelo | Swarthmore | Sr. | Aston, Pa. |
| G | John Hines | Christopher Newport | Jr. | Norfolk, Va. |
| G | Austin Grunder | Cortland | Sr. | Trumansburg, NY |
| F | Jeremy Beckler | Carleton | Sr. | Lino Lakes, Minn. |
| F | Dan Cook | St. John Fisher | Sr. | Honeoye Falls, NY |
| Fifth team | ||||
| G | Matt Helwig | North Central (Ill.) | Sr. | Aurora, Ill. |
| G | Jack Clement | Ohio Wesleyan | Sr. | Bellefontaine, Ohio |
| G | Ja’Zere Noel | Rowan | Jr. | Woodbury, NJ |
| G | Greg Rowson | Mary Washington | Sr. | Fairfax, Va. |
| F | Trey Barber | Christopher Newport | Jr. | Woodbridge, Va. |