The 2023 D3hoops.com All-America team is our 26th annual national awards. These are chosen by D3hoops.com staff in consultation with All-Region voting results from players nominated for All-Region.
Player of the Year: Morgan Morrison, F, Smith
Rookie of the Year: Mary Schleusner, F, Washington and Lee
Co-Coaches of the Year: Bill Broderick, Christopher Newport and Julie Fulks, Transylvania
| First team | ||||
| Pos. | Player | School | Year | Hometown |
| G | Elyce Knudsen | Millikin | Jr. | Philo, Ill. |
| G | Bridget Monaghan | Scranton | Sr. | Florham Park, NJ |
| F | Natalie Bruns | New York U. | Jr. | St. Louis, Mo. |
| F | Morgan Morrison | Smith | Sr. | Detroit, Mich. |
| F | Maggie Russell | Tufts | Jr. | Morristown, NJ |
| Second team | ||||
| Pos | Player | School | Year | Hometown |
| G | Madison Kellione | Transylvania | Sr. | Cynthiana, Ky. |
| G | Damaris Rodriguez | New Jersey City | Jr. | Secaucus, NJ |
| G | Brynn Serbin | Ohio Northern | Sr. | Pittsburgh, Pa. |
| F | Katie Titus | Rochester | Sr. | Penfield, NY |
| F | Gabby Timmer | Calvin | Sr. | Caledonia, Mich. |
| Third team | ||||
| Pos | Player | School | Year | Hometown |
| G | Megan Bauman | Babson | Sr. | East Lyme, Conn. |
| G | Brianna Fitzgerald | SUNY New Paltz | Jr. | Dix Hills, NY |
| G | Sidney Wagner | Trine | So. | Warsaw, Ind. |
| F | Reilly Campbell | Trinity (Conn.) | Jr. | Wallingford, Conn. |
| F | Aleah Grundahl | UW-Whitewater | Sr. | DeForest, Wis. |
| Fourth team | ||||
| Pos | Player | School | Year | Hometown |
| G | Kacie Carollo | UW-Whitewater | So. | Whitewater, Wis. |
| G | Sondra Fan | Christopher Newport | Sr. | Poquoson, Va. |
| F | Maya Arnott | Washington U. | Sr. | New York, NY |
| F | Anaya Simmons | Christopher Newport | Sr. | Williamsburg, Va. |
| C | Anna Barry | Eastern Connecticut | Sr. | Andover, Conn. |
| Fifth team | ||||
| Pos | Player | School | Year | Hometown |
| G | Meghan Graff | Bates | Sr. | South Portland, Maine |
| G | Summer McNulty | Elizabethtown | So. | Montoursville, Pa. |
| G | Arieona Rosborough | Mary Hardin-Baylor | So. | Mansfield, Texas |
| F | Ashlyn Milton | Trinity (Texas) | Sr. | Amarillo, Texas |
| F | Corinne Baker | Whitman | So. | Wauconda, Wash. |